//
you're reading...
CPD, Outstanding Lessons, Redesigning Classrooms

Lesson Planning: To Plan or Not to Plan

“To plan or not to plan, that is the question”, with apologies to William Shakespeare on whose 450th birthday I’m penning this blog post.  Lesson planning has potentially become a tragedy of Shakespearian proportion due to the amount of time teachers invest in it, sometimes with very little return for their efforts, in terms of improved learning in the class room.

Photo Credit: Intenteffect via Compfight cc

Photo Credit: Intenteffect via Compfight cc

Over the next few years teachers the length and breadth of England will be planning and re-planning their lessons in response to an almost endless onslaught of curriculum changes.  The curriculum has or is about to change across Key Stages 1, 2 and 3; there are new GCSE syllabi being introduced in 2015 and a whole raft of changes to A-level syllabi, some have already been introduced and others are about to be spewed out on the conveyor belt of curriculum change.

How Much Has Your Subject Changed?

I left wondering with all this curriculum change has my subject (Science with a leaning towards Chemistry) fundamentally changed that much over the years?  Understanding atomic theory; how elements arrangement in the Periodic Table, with its repeating patterns and various trends; particle theory and states of matter; reactions in terms of structure and bonding, endothermic and exothermic and rate with some dynamic equilibrium thrown in; not forgetting the mole as a bit of good old quantitative chemistry that makes you think all washed down with lashings of inorganic and organic chemistry.  It is pretty much the same now as when I started teaching over twenty five years ago.

Photo Credit: Cowboytoast via Compfight cc

Photo Credit: Cowboytoast via Compfight cc

There is also a need for students to develop a scientist’s “habits of mind” and ways of working which are quite subject specific as well as the more transferable skills of literacy, numeracy, planning and evaluating approaches to learning that will allow them to become increasingly self-sufficient in their learning as the opportunities and demands arise.  I kind of feel that pretty much nails it (with possibly the odd omission that my age now permits me).

Good Science is Good Science and always has been.

To Lesson Plan or Not to Lesson Plan?

My answer to this is no, yes and all in good time which I realise may not be particularly helpful.  I intend to blog out a few short posts, over the coming weeks, with some ideas and approaches to lesson planning, given its centrality to how teachers will be spending many of their waking hours over the coming years, to explain my thinking.

The How & What

It is important to get the how and what of the planning process right and also to get the how and what of the lesson plan right.

I’ve both written and seen lesson plans and observed lessons that are full of activities.  They tend to be busy but wasted opportunities for students’ learning.  I now find myself automatically and immediately correcting anyone who tells me what they or students will be doing in a lesson.  I can’t help myself and worry at times that my intervention is a bit too brusque possibly bordering on the rude.  I’m simply not interested, in the first instance, what teachers or students will be doing as I’m much more interested in what students will be expected to learn.  There should be no planning of lessons before this is determined.  Expected learning first, plan strategies and activities later.

Photo Credit: Jazz Hands by O Ryization on www.deviantart.com

Photo Credit: Jazz Hands by O Ryization on http://www.deviantart.com

Possibly the next piece of advice would be don’t plan lessons rather develop “learning flows”.  Planning lessons in isolation tends to lead to a disconnect in the learning rather than a structure and sequence that develops learning from its basic facts to deeper understanding or discrete skills to the use of a range of inter-related skills required to produce the desired outcome.  The extreme example of the individual lesson plan is the “show pony” or “jazz hands” observed lesson that is pulled out of the bag to bedazzle students and observers alike.

The how of the planning process is collaborative working.  Working with colleagues to develop the core expected or targeted learning simply increases the human capital available and engaged in the task – the outcome will be improved.  Sadly, too often I wrote (and I mean I wrote) schemes of work when I should have been writing schemes of learning (acknowledgement: Mark Healy @cijane02) or have seen schemes produced by the head of department or subject co-ordinator that were impoverished due to the lack of engagement of colleagues or a failure to secure a shared understanding of the content.  They should be developed collaboratively.  This planning is a fantastic professional development opportunity where teachers can discuss and agree the big concepts and ideas; how to build towards them and the potential misconceptions students develop or minefields in a particular area of study.  It helps further secure teachers’ subject knowledge and its application in the class room.

Photo Credit: Kokeshi via Compfight cc

Photo Credit: Kokeshi via Compfight cc

Schemes of learning need to contain what must be learnt and not necessarily how the content should be taught.  People teach how they teach and there is often a huge amount of energy required to change this.

It has been suggested that it is easier to change a teacher’s religion than it is to change their pedagogy.

Simply putting a different teaching strategy in a scheme of learning is largely ineffectual in changing teachers’ methodology. Allied to this the complexity required to determine a particular strategy, for a given learning intention, at a particular point in time with a certain group of students most pedagogy is best left out of the schemes of work.

This isn’t an “anything goes” type of argument as some teaching strategies have proved more effective over time.  It is much more about accepting there are different strategies, a number of which would be effective, to ensure the required learning occurs.  There needs to be a level of professional autonomy to allow the teacher to choose the one s/he feels is most appropriate.  This approach also allows for the body of knowledge, about what does and doesn’t constitute effective teaching, to grow and develop over time as long as there is a process of rigorous evaluation.  We have not yet reached the point that we know everything there is to know about teaching so why pretend otherwise?

Once the backbone of the curriculum has been determined and secured then it is time to plan lessons or my preference is a series of lessons.  This is the creative and fun part where teachers can decide how to deliver the learning by either planning lessons on their own or with colleagues. The what of the lesson planning process focuses on the pedagogy as the content should have already been agreed.

Below is an attempt to produce a visual schema of part of the process described above.  It is for planning a series of lessons but could be used for individual lessons if you prefer.

Outstanding T&L Planner

It comes from the post #OutstandingIn10Plus10 which is a professional development programme delivered at St. Mary’s for the first time this academic year (at the bottom of the post the above resource is available to download).

This is likely to be a mini-series of posts written around some inter-related ideas:

Lesson Planning: Start At the End

Lesson Planning: End at the Start

Happy lesson planning, or maybe not or maybe in time.

Postscript:

I’ve changed the term schemes of work to schemes of learning after this nudge from Mark:

With thanks to Mark Healy @cijane02

With thanks to Mark Healy @cijane02

Advertisements

Discussion

10 thoughts on “Lesson Planning: To Plan or Not to Plan

  1. Another top, top post Stephen. This shows the importance of departmental collaboration with schemes of work. Planning becomes so much easier if schemes are well written, organic (ie constantly being tweaked/ added to by members of the dept) and state the end point for the lesson (series of lessons)- i.e. what we actually want students to have learned/demonstrated/achieved (particularly if the verbs of solo taxonomy are used). I nodded all the way through this. Look forward to the next one….
    Damian

    Posted by mrbenney | April 24, 2014, 8:13 pm
  2. Reblogged this on The Echo Chamber.

    Posted by heatherfblog | April 25, 2014, 6:07 pm
  3. I found this very interesting the basics of chemistry are timeless. As are probably most other subjects. I really like the visual schema. The opportunity to plan new schemes that specifically incorporation of SOLO and Hattie’s visability is such a good idea. However the best part and the most challenging (for me anyway) is deliberately planning for that magical and elusive ‘flow’. Most thought-provoking, thank you for sharing this.

    Posted by janettesmith999 | April 25, 2014, 7:20 pm

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Pingback: ORRsome blog posts from the week that was Week 16 | high heels and high notes - April 30, 2014

  2. Pingback: Lesson Planning: Start At the End | @LeadingLearner - May 10, 2014

  3. Pingback: Lesson Planning: To Plan or Not to Plan | @LeadingLearner | Learning Curve - May 11, 2014

  4. Pingback: Lesson Planning: End At the Start | @LeadingLearner - May 17, 2014

  5. Pingback: What is good teaching? Following it up. | mrbenney - September 14, 2014

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

New Book: Liminal Leadership

If you're interested in finding out more about how Mangahigh can support your Maths Curriculum please click me

The Teacher Development Trust a national charity supporting effective professional development (please click to find out more)

Blog Stats

  • 839,739 hits

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 20,842 other followers

Follow @LeadingLearner on WordPress.com

COPYRIGHT LICENCE

#5MinMarkingPlan

It won't get your marking done in five minutes but will help your structure your marking so you and the students get the most out of it.

#5MinBehaviourPlan

Getting the behaviour of students right, in the class room, is the challenge for every teacher. This simple planner will take you through the main stages required to help you achieve a purposeful learning envionment

#Outstandingin10Plus10

Ideas and the thinking behind a professional development to help improve the quality of teaching and learning. Keep the learning tight, the lesson plan loose and focus on the learners

Planning to Get Behaviour Right: Research Plus Experience

The thinking behind the #5MinBehaviourPlan and our whole school approach to managing behaviour.

Education for Wisdom

Why the four knowledge dimensions (covering knowledge and skills) and a moral compass are at the heart of an outstanding education.

When Feedback Met Bloom

A look at the power of Feedback to students using Bloom's four knowledge dimensions

%d bloggers like this: