you're reading...
Leadership, Redesigning Schools

Hattie, Hymer, Tomsett, Cameron and All that Jazz

It’s great to be able to blog about how I’ve shared the stage with John Hattie, John Tomsett, Barry Hymer and the real David Cameron; more rhetoric than reality.  Speaking at the same conference isn’t quite the same as sharing the stage but since I spoke in the same room I thought a bit of exaggeration for effect might be allowed.

Photo Credit: Marc Wellekotter via Flickr cc

Photo Credit: Marc Wellekotter via Flickr cc

The following is based on short notes I took at the time; I can’t be totally sure they are one hundred percent accurate.  As with all great conferences it affirmed our overall direction of travel whilst challenging both our current and future practice.  In short there is a lot more to do before we are fully aligned and truly coherent in both policy and practice.

“The Greatest Power You Have is Controlling the Narrative of Your School”

John Hattie kicked the day off with the call for teachers to be evaluators; know thy impact.  Basically just about everything works so it’s no good saying “I’ve evidence this works”.  John’s meta-analysis has now looked at 12000+ research projects and apart from the obvious, e.g. bullying, moving schools too often, not much harms children (95-97% of strategies or approaches have a positive impact)

The question is what works best; what has most impact?  Three big questions leaders should be asking and seeking to answer are:

What do you mean by impact?  We need to be clear what we mean by progress; we can’t leave this to chance nor assume that we all have the same definition in the same.   Using the phrase “progress or growth” suggested that there is something in addition to purely academic outcomes that we should be providing in a great education

What’s the magnitude of the impact?  Are we getting a year’s progress or growth for a year’s input?  How could we get more and what to do if we are getting less are obvious questions.  What does the progress of low, middle, high or high attaining pupils look like in classes?  For example, looking at pupils’ work and its improvement over time – a week, month term or year – is a relatively easy task for each and every teacher to do.  Don’t wait for a leader to come along and complete a book scrutiny; take the lead.  What aspects of progress are you pleased, content and disappointed with?  This forms the basis of evaluating and reflecting on what is the impact of your teaching.

How many children are getting a year’s progress?  It’s the equity question and collectively we are struggling to find the answer.  The gap just keeps getting wider the longer children are in school and the disadvantaged pupils with high prior attainment are the ones losing out the most.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

“Building a Coalition of Success”

The phrase just sings to you; no teachers left behind, take them all with you.  Given what looks like an increasing and deepening crisis in teacher numbers focussing on development and retention is becoming a must do for school leaders.  If teachers are having a high impact leave them alone; don’t start firing silver bullets at them or insist they use your pet theories or ideas.  Look for evidence of which teachers are having impact and insist they share their practice; people who are doing good and great things need to share.  The role of the leader is to get people together, within a trust based culture, and build the confidence and belief that together we can impact; collective teacher efficacy.

“Cluster Bombs of Distraction”

What a perfect one liner coming on the day Nicky Morgan MP, Secretary of State for Education, announced a U-turn on forced academisation which in hours looked more like a Z-turn, as described by Laura McInerney.  We are faced with forced academisation via a different route and timescale.  Labour controlled councils in the North first, courtesy of Ofsted judgements, followed by financial tipping points for everyone else as more schools decided to become academies and cuts to the Direct Schools Grant reduce capacity to practically nothing in all other local authorities.

Moral Issue


SamFr Tweet

We’re largely focusing on the wrong things; teachers, school leaders and politicians shouldn’t confuse personal education preferences (I rather like this approach/way of educating children and young people) with strategies and approaches that have significant impact.  Once you’ve completed massive structural change, with all the costs, upheaval and angst, you are still left with a school to run; sound of hammer hitting the nail on the head.

 “What CPD has Impacted Significantly on Your Practice?”

The above was John Tomsett’s question to Alex Quigley (@HuntingEnglish) as part of the process in which he was appointed as Director of Learning & Research at Huntington School.  Think about it for a moment; it’s a killer question.  Add in so “what evidence do you have of the impact over six months to a year later” and it’s a question not many teachers would be able to answer.

“What is the problem that your CPD is trying to fix?”

One of the parting shots from John Hattie was about the problem that your CPD is trying to fix alongside the fact he has only found three pieces of research about how to scale up success in schools?  One of the things that fascinates about John Tomsett’s work is how he is trying to find practical answers to such massive questions.  Once we’ve invested time in something as school leaders it has to work.  We’re not seeing failures as successes; great we won’t spend time doing that any more or doing it that way.  Stopping doing something, we’ve implemented, even if it doesn’t have significant impact is really difficult.

Leading Teacher Learning & Development is the Head teacher’s main thing and John has gone about it in a systematic and evidence informed way.  He has changes structures and systems to meet the school’s purpose rather than the other way around.  With lots of talk about what doesn’t work around these days it was good to hear about what does work.  Using the much maligned one day course John explained how using the criteria below from Developing Great Teaching (Teacher Development Trust) the potential impact could be transformed from a 2.5 to an 11/14.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

  • Collaborating in ongoing improvement together
  • Focus on specific, valued outcomes for specific pupils
  • Practical in own class/school & engagement with theory
  • Sustained (30-50 hours) and iterative
  • Expert facilitation
  • Formative Assessment
  • Subject/topic-specific content and pedagogy

As teachers and funds become more limited great CPD, which has an impact on pupils’ outcomes, is a way of keeping the first and maximising the impact of both.

The Hymer and Cameron bits will follow; just need to get them typed up first.  Thanks to Osiris for a great Leadership Conference Day 1 and if you’re interested in Day 2 there are details here.



5 thoughts on “Hattie, Hymer, Tomsett, Cameron and All that Jazz

  1. A really useful summary and plenty to think about. CPD evaluation is something I’m trying to crack this year. I’ve gone for establishing clear objectives based on ‘fixing’ the lack of progress by some groups of pupils, then using existing processes like learning walks and book looks as evaluative evidence. We’ll see if it works!

    Posted by Caseby's Casebook | May 8, 2016, 8:31 am
  2. This is a massive undertaking of both thought and subsequent actions, but at the heart of major turning points and developments we need to consider “motivation”. Amongst teachers and SLT there needs to be a consensual drive towards objectives ie. we need to get as many students achieving as possible. The theory holds fast, but then your “client base” is made up of a plethora of young people all with their own drives/ ambitions/ problems/ psychological strengths and weaknesses/ academic ability range/ pedigree/ fears and hopes and this is where the motivation factor is critical but often lacking. I think the most important thing is to make sure that the youngsters in our establishments are hungry and driven to succeed academically. Education needs to be seen as the catalyst for success in life. Go to an African school and you have 50+ students in a shed hanging on every word of the English teacher because they know this is the way to better themselves. Education needs to be seen by every student as the way to better themselves and to see every single lesson as a further step forward. I measure the effectiveness of my teaching not just through test results but through relationship building with the students – I know how they feel about an aspect of the lesson because they will tell me – they don’t switch off if the going gets tough, they know this is important, so I work even harder with them. Mine is a skills-based subject (languages) and every single lesson counts. CPD should be a permanent consideration all the time – how could I improve on that lesson/ how could I make teaching the imperfect tense clearer?/ what was the immediate feedback from the students?/ what is the very first thing I need to do next lesson to make this clearer? The very first thing I think about when I get in front of the class is “how do I make the students hungry to achieve this? What is the bigger picture as well as the WILFs and success criteria?” The main issue is motivation at all levels – everything you do/plan and say needs to be there to push your students, ……but also yourself as a teacher forwards. Success breeds success.
    As always, thanks for the food for thought, Stephen!

    Posted by Stuart Robathan | May 8, 2016, 9:09 am
    • Barry Hymer picked up on a number of themes you rightly raised above. Mindset thinking needs to go deep; beyond the poster and odd phrase to something which becomes part of the heartbeat of a school and its young people

      Posted by LeadingLearner | May 8, 2016, 9:15 am
  3. Reblogged this on rwaringatl.

    Posted by R Waring | May 9, 2016, 11:19 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Leadership: Being, Knowing, Doing (New Book)

Liminal Leadership


Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 32,090 other subscribers
Follow @LeadingLearner on WordPress.com

Blog Stats

  • 1,605,563 hits


%d bloggers like this: